Butter

Appearance
Butter has yellow-blond hair tied into a ponytail. Her eyes are a shiny light grey and she wears pink blush. Butter has a heart ahoge. She wears a white shirt underneath a blue dress. Sissy observes that Butter is very young-looking, wondering if she is a "forever girl. Her hair seems to be inspired by warm butter”

Personality
In the first playthrough, Butter appears sweet and gentle. She is very cheerful and loves her boyfriend Bread a lot, who she has known since they were both children.

In the second playthrough, Butter becomes terrified upon learning that Sissy is a human who doesn't see herself as food. With Bread's help she locks Sissy in her basement, fearing that Sissy will tell others about the town and she will be forced back to civilization and her abusive family.

Minigames
In the first playthrough minigame, Sissy (player) has to collect the ingredients to make a meal without walking over spaces you walked on previously.

In the second playthrough minigame, you have to escape the shaft without Dumpling catching you.

Playthrough #1
Bread and Butter are the first townspeople Dumpling introduces Sissy to. Butter is happy and caring. She loves Bread a lot. They are both joyful about Sissy admitting she is a chef, even if she's not professional level. Butter shows her passionate love for food and welcomes Sissy to return any time.

Playthrough #2
Butter's demeanor completely changes upon learning that Sissy is a human. She becomes terrified and the couple locks Sissy in their basement. She reveals to Sissy that she came from an abusive family where her parents would frequently lock her away without food, to the point that they had to lock her away from others just to hide her emaciated state (possibly explaining why she looks like such a tiny young "forever-girl"). Bread helped her escape and come to Food Town, where she never has to worry about where her next meal is coming from or if her abusers will find her. She's terrified that if Sissy tells anyone about Food Town the authorities will come disband the town and return her to her parents. She is willing to keep Sissy captive or kill her to keep the town and her fantasy life safe.